Let be a binary relation on the set , where if the product of and is square of an integer. Which of the following properties is/are satisfied by ?
- (A)
Reflexive
- (B)
Symmetric
- (C)
Transitive
- (D)
Antisymmetric
Let be a binary relation on the set , where if the product of and is square of an integer. Which of the following properties is/are satisfied by ?
Reflexive
Symmetric
Transitive
Antisymmetric
ANSWER
The relation is reflexive, symmetric and transitive (an equivalence relation), but not antisymmetric: options A, B and C.
Official answer: A, B, CSource: Official answer key, GATE 2026 CS2 (IIT Guwahati)
exactly when is the square of an integer.
Reflexive: is a perfect square for every , so for all . True.
Symmetric: , so if is a perfect square then so is . True.
Transitive: let and with integers. Then , so . Thus is an integer and the square of a rational number. A rational whose square is an integer must itself be an integer, so is the square of an integer and . True.
Equivalently, is a square exactly when and have the same square-free part, so is an equivalence relation. For example, on the classes are , , , , , , .
Antisymmetric: since , and , but . So is not antisymmetric. False.
Therefore is reflexive, symmetric and transitive: options A, B and C.
KEY IDEA
is a perfect square exactly when and have the same square-free part, so is an equivalence relation. It is therefore reflexive, symmetric and transitive, and it fails antisymmetry as soon as two distinct numbers share a class.
WATCH OUT FOR
Doubting transitivity because looks like a fraction. Since is an integer and a rational square, it is an integer square. Another slip is to treat a symmetric relation as antisymmetric because the pairs look 'ordered'. Here and are both in .
From the GATE 2026 CS2 paper. Every question of this paper · Download the full paper · All 8 Sets & relations questions, with notes