IAE Academy

GATE 2022 CS GA Q.9: solution and answer

GATE 2022 · CSGA Q.9 · 2 marks · MCQ

The corners and mid-points of the sides of a triangle are named using the distinct letters P, Q, R, S, T and U, but not necessarily in the same order. Consider the following statements:

  • The line joining P and R is parallel to the line joining Q and S.
  • P is placed on the side opposite to the corner T.
  • S and U cannot be placed on the same side.

Which one of the following statements is correct based on the above information?

  1. (A)

    P cannot be placed at a corner

  2. (B)

    S cannot be placed at a corner

  3. (C)

    U cannot be placed at a mid-point

  4. (D)

    R cannot be placed at a corner

See the question in the paper

Answer and solution

ANSWER

Option (B): S cannot be placed at a corner.

Official answer: BSource: Official answer key, GATE 2022 CS (IIT Kharagpur)

  1. Name the triangle ABC with mid-points (of BC), (of CA), (of AB). T is a corner, and by symmetry let . Then P lies on the side opposite A, so .

  2. Which lines through two of the six points are parallel? Take , , , so , , . The only parallel pairs are a mid-line and the side it is parallel to: (points B, a, C), (points A, b, C), (points A, c, B). The medians are not parallel to any other joining line. So one of the lines PR, QS is a mid-line (two mid-points) and the other lies along the parallel side (two of the three points on it).

  3. Case 1: PR is the mid-line. Then P and R are mid-points, and P is on BC, so . If , the mid-line , so Q, S are the two points of AB other than A, namely , and . B and C share the side BC, so S cannot be B. Hence , a mid-point. If , the mid-line , so and . Again C shares BC with B, so , a mid-point.

  4. Case 2: QS is the mid-line, so S is a mid-point. Examples that satisfy all three statements: , , , , , . Here , P is on BC opposite A, and b (on AC) and a (on BC) share no side. The mid-lines and do not work in this case. For , and , but a lies on BC and c lies on AB, both sides through B. For , and , but a lies on BC and b lies on AC, both sides through C.

  5. In every valid arrangement S is a mid-point, so S cannot be at a corner. Option (B) is correct.

  6. The other options fail, using the arrangement of step 4: P is the corner C, so (A) is false. R is the corner B, so (D) is false. U is the mid-point , so (C) is false.

KEY IDEA

In a triangle with its three mid-points, the only parallel lines are a mid-line and the side it is parallel to. So PR and QS must be a mid-line and its parallel side, and the mid-line's end points are both mid-points.

WATCH OUT FOR

Assuming a parallel pair can come from any two lines, for example a median and a side. Or checking only one arrangement and calling an option false or true from it, without going through every placement that satisfies the three statements.

From the GATE 2022 CS paper. Every question of this paper · Download the full paper · All 39 Geometry questions, with notes

More Geometry questions