IAE Academy

GATE 2023 BT GA Q.6: solution and answer

GATE 2023 · BTGA Q.6 · 2 marks · MCQ

Human beings are one among many creatures that inhabit an imagined world. In this imagined world, some creatures are cruel. If in this imagined world, it is given that the statement “Some human beings are not cruel creatures” is FALSE, then which of the following set of statement(s) can be logically inferred with certainty?
(i) All human beings are cruel creatures.
(ii) Some human beings are cruel creatures.
(iii) Some creatures that are cruel are human beings.
(iv) No human beings are cruel creatures.

  1. (A)

    only (i)

  2. (B)

    only (iii) and (iv)

  3. (C)

    only (i) and (ii)

  4. (D)

    (i), (ii) and (iii)

See the question in the paper

Answer and solution

ANSWER

Option (D): statements (i), (ii) and (iii) can be inferred with certainty.

Official answer: DSource: Official answer key, GATE 2023 BT (IIT Kanpur)

  1. If "Some human beings are not cruel creatures" is FALSE, its contradictory must be TRUE. The contradictory of "Some H are not C" is "All H are C". So (i) "All human beings are cruel creatures" is true.

  2. The passage says human beings inhabit this imagined world, so at least one human being exists. Every human being is cruel, so some human beings are cruel creatures. So (ii) is true.

  3. "Some H are C" converts to "Some C are H". So some cruel creatures are human beings, and (iii) is true.

  4. (iv) "No human beings are cruel creatures" contradicts (ii), which is true, so (iv) is false.

  5. Exactly (i), (ii) and (iii) can be inferred with certainty. This is option (D).

KEY IDEA

The negation of "Some A are not B" is "All A are B". Check that the class is non-empty before concluding "Some", then convert "Some A are B" to "Some B are A".

WATCH OUT FOR

Choosing option (C) by forgetting that "Some human beings are cruel creatures" can be reversed to give (iii). Another slip is to doubt (ii) because "All" does not by itself imply "Some", when the passage does say that human beings exist.

From the GATE 2023 BT paper. Every question of this paper · Download the full paper · All 72 Reasoning questions, with notes

More Reasoning questions