and are functions of and , respectively, and for all real values of and . Which one of the following options is necessarily TRUE for all and ?
- (A)
and
- (B)
constant
- (C)
constant and constant
- (D)
and are functions of and , respectively, and for all real values of and . Which one of the following options is necessarily TRUE for all and ?
and
constant
constant and constant
ANSWER
Option (B): constant.
Official answer: BSource: Official answer key, GATE 2023 CS (IIT Kanpur)
depends only on and depends only on , and must hold for every pair of real numbers.
Fix . Then for every , and does not change with . So takes one fixed value at all : is constant.
Fix . Then for every , so is constant too.
Writing and , the condition at any one pair gives . So for some constant . This is option (B).
Option (A) is not necessarily true: can be any number, such as , not only .
Option (C) is false: it says both functions are not constant, which contradicts what we derived.
Option (D) simplifies to , that is . This holds only when , so it is not necessarily true.
KEY IDEA
If a function of alone equals a function of alone for all independent real and , neither can vary, so both equal the same constant.
WATCH OUT FOR
Choosing (A) or (D) by assuming the common constant must be zero. The constant can be any real number, so only "constant" is guaranteed.
From the GATE 2023 CS paper. Every question of this paper · Download the full paper · All 72 Reasoning questions, with notes